Are special lubricants, waxes, or powder substances that are applied over the surface of a board, necessary in order to achieve the best "speed" in competition crokinole?
The debate continues......! Let's look at the history of the game. Crokinole play-be it family, folksy, or seriously tournament-going back to the mid-1860s, generally did not involve the use of applied substances to artificially raise the "speed" of a crokinole playing surface. The sealing of playing surfaces has evolved through a long line of various products-shellacs, varnishes, oils, French-rubbed wax treatments, urethanes, varethanes, lacquers and more. Apart from the regular maintenance of cleaning, dusting, or polishing to maintain the original surface that may have been applied to a quality crokinole board, the application of a "floating" powder or granular substance is a relatively new phenomenon. When the World Crokinole Championships (WCC) began in 1999, it was necessary to borrow a large number of boards to accommodate the 300+ players who had registered for the event. In an effort to create a "level playing field" between the wide variety of crokinole boards, it was determined to use a very fine, granular shuffleboard-type wax. As that event has grown, and a larger number of more uniform playing boards has become available, the use of liberal amounts of such substances has dwindled, but-to the chagrin of many-not entirely disappeared. Throughout the world there are numerous board games that rely upon the regular application of non-adhering waxes or lubricants. Shuffleboard and carrom are among the most common. In the case of authentic (Indian) carrom, assorted boric acid powders, mespi dust, chalk, talcum, and even potato starch has been used to "grease" the field of play so as to provide the opportunity for multiple bouncing from rail to rail-similar to the movement of balls from cushion to cushion on a billiard table. Crokinole does not work that way. The installation of good latex-clad posts and a regularly maintained, smooth playing surface do not require that type of "pucks-on-ice" action. Numerous gaming associations and gatherings of players who may have used "floating" lubricants on non-crokinole gaming surfaces are the individuals chiefly responsible for the introduction of their use in modern crokinole. However, it has been noted that a crokinole surface with such products on it can actually become too fast. If all "drag" coefficient is reduced, the game can become unpredictable. A board that is not entirely level-perhaps even on a tilt of only ½ degree, may allow discs to become so mobile that they will actually "curl" off the playing field. Longtime crokinole players, and some of the world's best competitors revile such products.
Additional concerns include:
1. the fact that boric acid powders are somewhat toxic. Many manufacturers have been unable or reluctant to fully list the ingredients of their products. Use of them in the presence of children is inadvisable.
2. The potential for spillage on a smooth floor surface can prove dangerous.
3. Shuffleboards are generally finished with an exceptionally hard and durable topcoat (usually urethanes) which allow for the constant use of granular lubricants. The best tournament crokinole boards are generally finished with fine-quality lacquers. The regular use of external lubricants is frequently abrasive to a crokinole board surface, thus destroying the original smoothness of a high-quality board. Numerous owners of our best tournament boards have lamented their frequent use of such lubricants as the original finish of their board has been all but destroyed.
4. Use of such products on a crokinole playing surface that has routered lines (as opposed to painted or silk-screened lines) allows build-up in these channels that offers an unpredictable disc-to-surface response.
5. And, they are messy!